In an other wise relatively harmless article that was in yesterday’s Daily News, Mike Lupica said something that really got under my skin:
Cano covers No. 3 and No. 4 in the order, he covers no-show Nick Johnson and Curtis Granderson and Brian Cashman letting Johnny Damon and Hideki Matsui just walk out the door.
I’m not mad about the Cano praise, but I’m peeved by the comments on Granderson and Cashman. Why is Lupica blaming Granderson for getting hurt? It’s also worth noting that Granderson has been hitting well of late. Including last night, he’s batting .324/.390/.595 with four doubles and two homers–one a grand slam–since returning from his groin injury. I’m not sure what Lupica’s watching, but that comment seems totally unfounded.
As for the shot at Cashman? That’s completely unnecessary. The Yankees made offers to both Hideki Matsui and Johnny Damon and they definitely made every effort to retain Johnny Damon, even offering him a two year contract when no one else was doing so.
How are the two of them performing? Matsui started hot, hit a skid, and is now back up to respectability with a .344 wOBA. Damon has cooled off as well, but is at a .354 wOBA, which is still good. Not including last night’s game, Brett Gardner’s wOBA is .377 and he’s been worth 1.4 WAR thus far, compared to Damon’s 1.0.
The Yankees are definitely doing more than okay without Matsui and Damon and Lupica’s comment is certainly out of line. But, then again, should I really expect something different out of him at this point?
subtlety is the best response.
These writers are merely being contrarians and it is their job to stir up a response.
Deprive him of his soapbox by pointing out his error and let the readers make their own judgments (agree with you) rightclue(Quote)
[Reply To This Comment]
Of all of the obnoxious writers without a clue, Lupica is the worst. I stopped reading him decades ago. oldpep(Quote)
[Reply To This Comment]
The Granderson deal was a bust. Overall his performance is lackluster, in spite of the last few games. Detroit definitely got the better end of that deal. Austin Jackson is performing great — noticeably better than Granderson, and is a lot cheaper for Detroit than Granderson. I’d rather have Phil Coke and Austin Jackson in the organization instead of Granderson, and Matsui instead of either Granderson or the complete dud, Nick Johnson, that replaced him. the 2 major deals the Yankees did at the start of the season — Granderson and Johnson, were both failures with the Yankees getting the short end. They would be better without them. BJ Mason(Quote)
[Reply To This Comment]
“I’m not sure what Lupica’s watching, but that comment seems totally unfounded. ”
Haha…imagine that. Tripp(Quote)
[Reply To This Comment]