The Joba Chamberlain issue is incredibly polarizing, as seemingly anyone who writes about baseball for a living has chimed in with their opinion. Yesterday, Wally Matthews checked in with his entirely predictable thoughts:

“We’re just trying to be smart about it,” Girardi said. “We’re not trying to overwork him his first time in the rotation for the whole year. There’s a history that has been studied by our people and this is what we feel is best.”

The Yankees’ “studies” seem to have omitted guys such as Tom Seaver, Bob Gibson, Warren Spahn and Nolan Ryan, all of whom threw 200-plus inning seasons at tender ages and went on to long, essentially injury-free careers, and ignored many of his contemporaries, such as Justin Verlander, Tim Lincecum and Felix Hernandez, who have done the same early in their careers so far without incident.

And they overlook the case history of Joba’s teammate, A.J. Burnett, who also was babied early in his career but still has suffered one injury after another.

So much for scientific “studies.” If a guy is going to get hurt, he’s going to get hurt, and no amount of coddling is going to prevent it, because at some point, they all have to go out on the field and play.

Wally’s theory is that caution should be thrown to the wind, and apparently these studies should be thrown out because some players have stayed healthy despite throwing plenty of innings. Of course, this ignores the concept of the exception proving the rule- the fact that everyone notes the same few pitchers suggests that they are the exception, and that many players who actually got hurt have been lost to the sands of time. Joel Sherman, in what seems to be a direct response to Matthews, brought up another critique:

I KNOW this is going to annoy many people of a certain age, but please stop comparing Joba Chamberlain’s innings to those of Tom Seaver and Bob Gibson and Nolan Ryan and Steve Carlton…..

Gibson did not pitch against a designated hitter. Aside from perhaps the 3-4-5 hitters, Gibson did not face many home run threats, so he could conserve against the tops and bottoms of lineups……

Gibson never faced hitters who watched their at-bats against him before and during games to pick up patterns. Gibson did not face an era of players steeped in the value of the long at-bat and drawing walks. Gibson enjoyed a larger strike zone and — at times — a higher mound. He did not use a more tightly-wound ball against lighter, whip-like bats designed to zip through the zone for more damage. And we haven’t even mentioned steroids yet.

If this were the NL in 1970, I would champion Chamberlain pitching 200-plus innings. But he is pitching in the AL in 2009. No batting practice fastballs. No soft spots in a batting order. Entire lineups addicted to working the count. Maple bats. Etc., etc., etc…..

Maybe genetics or throwing styles meant these guys were going to be injured whether they were babied or not. But to not have a plan to protect the most precious commodity in the sport is negligent…..

“You can’t ignore a plan because he has New York on his chest rather than Scranton,” Cashman said. “That would be irresponsible. That means the plan doesn’t mean anything, so why have a plan?”

Sherman’s article is about as lucid an argument you will find on the subject, and I strongly encourage you to read the entire thing. As he notes, the players of yore that Matthews brings up were playing in an era where pitching was king. SInce then, every single advance in the game has been tilted towards hitters, particularly in the AL. It is almost impossible to compare the workloads.

The Yankees are being cautious with their most precious asset, so that he pays off in the long term. Anything else would be shortsighted, and anathema to the long term goals of the organization. They created a plan, and are now sticking to it no matter what the situation. It is the right thing to do.

No Responses to “Joel Sherman Dominates Wally Matthews On Joba Issue”

  1. I’d just like to note that although he wasn’t technically injured, Justin Verlander had a very disappointing 2008 season which saw his walks, hits and era skyrocket and his strikeouts decline. This after coming off two seasons where the young righty was worked exceptionally hard and threw over 200 innings.

    In fact I recall many scouts questioning if he was hurt or feeling the effects of his workload, as even his fastball was velocity down.

    He is back on track this year, however the Tigers lost a season of productivity from him (92 ERA+) due possibly to being worked to hard too soon.  (Quote)

    [Reply To This Comment]

  2. If I ever agreed with the likes of Matthews, King, Kruk, Reynolds, Williams, etc., it would force me to re-evaluate my place on this planet. It’s amazing to me that people so dumb can act like they know so much.

    God bless their ignorance.  (Quote)

    [Reply To This Comment]

  3. The first time Spahn threw for 200+ innings he was 26. The first time Ryan did he was 25. Ditto Gibson. Why would he bring up 3 pitchers who didn’t have any 200+ innings seasons before they were 25 to show that it’s OK to throw 200+ innings before a pitcher is 25.
    Add the DH, bigger K zone, higher mound, etc mentioned in the original post, and you have to wonder just what the hell these guys are thinking.  (Quote)

    [Reply To This Comment]

    Mark Da Rosa Reply:

    Yeah exactly, Nolan Ryan was in the league for I believe 5 years before he broke 200 innings. Pitchers in this modern day that have suffered the effects of being overworked are Fausto Carmona, Edison Volquez, Kerry Wood, Mark Prior, Justin Verlander (bad year), and Scott Kazmir.  (Quote)

    [Reply To This Comment]

    The other Chris H Reply:

    Verlander really bounced back though this year… I still can’t believe the gun when he takes the mound, how do you consistently hit 98-100?  (Quote)

    [Reply To This Comment]

    Yankee1010 Reply:

    Because Matthews is a complete moron. Honestly, he has no clue what he’s talking about.

    He is completely unable to pick up on any nuance. Essentially, if it was up to his own mental machinations, he’d probably be driving a car with square wheels.  (Quote)

    [Reply To This Comment]

  4. Glad to read Joel Shermans’ article and agree with it.
    Jim Kaat (and some of the older guys) have mentioned these things…back in the day, when things were different for everyone playing baseball.
    The point being, now is now, then …is history. We play by different rules now, with bigger and faster players. Kids are not ready for 200+ innings (of the AL East) at 23 years old.  (Quote)

    [Reply To This Comment]

  5. Felix Hernandez didn’t get “babied” but at the same time he didn’t hit 200 innings until his 3rd year in the league, he had 190 in the two previous seasons but he didn’t immediately get 220 innings or anything.  (Quote)

    [Reply To This Comment]

Leave a Reply



You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>

© 2011 TYU Suffusion theme by Sayontan Sinha